Three items in this newsletter for your information:
- AJC’s “Governors United Against BDS” initiative update
- SFMEW speaker (June, 2016) Bassem Eid’s Times of Israel Editorial
- Beit Tikvah Cantor Ephraim Herrera Concert, June 4, 3:00 pm
1. AJC’s Governors United Against BDS initiative – an update
Back in July, 2016 we asked you to write to the Governor to sign onto the AJC “Governors United Against BDS” campaign. In November we were pleased to inform you that, because of your action, Governor Martinez had signed the statement. Now we’ve gotten word that all governors in all 50 states and the Mayor of Washington, DC have signed this pledge.
The AJC puts it best:
Republican and Democratic governors from coast to coast are now united in their support for Israel and their public rejection of the anti-Israel boycott, divestment, and sanctions (BDS) campaign.
We’re proud to announce that AJC’s Governors United Against BDS initiative has attained the backing of all 50 U.S. governors and the mayor of Washington, D.C.!
This initiative irrefutably demonstrates that support for Israel transcends partisan politics and that leaders from across the country continue to stand with the Jewish state.
While sometimes it’s hard to believe it, Israel is a uniting force in US politics!
2. SFMEW speaker (June, 2016) Bassem Eid’s Times of Israel Editorial
You’ll recall that back on June 23, 2016 SFMEW sponsored Bassem Eid, who spoke in Santa Fe. You can see a summary of his talk and listen to the talk on our website here. Ten days ago he wrote this editorial in the Times of Israel, indirectly relevant to the upcoming Trump visit to Israel.
May 8, 2017, 10:07 am
I know from speaking with my fellow Palestinians every day that the average Palestinian is mostly concerned with putting food on the table and educating their children. The average Palestinian wants dignity more than identity. They want employment for themselves and their children. Palestinians want an economy that provides meaningful jobs.
Nothing is being done to establish an economic infrastructure in the Palestinian territories because no one is willing to invest in the West Bank, let alone Gaza. There is practically no Palestinian-controlled industry in the West Bank or Gaza.
We Palestinians suffer from a lack of leadership. Our leaders – both from Hamas and Fatah – are corrupt. Mahmoud Abbas was elected President in 2005 for a four-year term, and he is still in power, despite the fact that there has been no election since 2005. He refuses to hold elections. We Palestinians have no legitimate leadership. Even though the world still pretends that he is the legitimate President, no one, including Israel, believes that he represents anyone anymore. He has no authority to speak with Israel about peace or a permanent solution.
Palestinian leaders have mishandled negotiations so badly that today, the very idea of a two-state solution, is in tatters. Although most Israelis still wish to reach such a solution, there is practically no confidence among Israelis that it can be achieved under current circumstances.
Hamas, which has repeatedly demanded the destruction of Israel, is clearly not interested in a two-state solution. There is little indication that Abbas wants it either because he refuses to even discuss that possibility with Israel. More importantly, Abbas has no credibility to deliver such a solution.
When Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said, “I think that anyone who moves to establish a Palestinian state today, and evacuate areas, is giving radical Islam an area from which to attack the State of Israel”, he was right. Abbas has a weak hold on power. If Israel evacuated the West Bank, she would quickly be replaced by Hamas.
For both Fatah and Hamas, the conflict has become a business and a means of retaining power. They profit from the conflict financially and politically, so they do everything to ensure that it continues.
Despite Israel’s complete withdrawal from Gaza in 2005, because of the violent nature of Hamas’ rule over Gaza and their continued attacks on Israel, we Palestinians are anything but free and independent.
The Palestinians in Gaza depend upon four powers over which they have no influence: Israel; Egypt; the Palestinian Authority; and Hamas. Hamas is, of course, the de facto authority in Gaza. Israel and Egypt control traffic in and out Gaza in order to limit Hamas’ military capacity and its ability to wage war. The PA has official oversight over Gaza, but in practical terms, it cannot do anything without Hamas.
The Palestinians in Gaza are held hostage by these four powers, and Hamas is the one responsible for the situation. Hamas uses and sacrifices the Palestinians for its own political purposes. Every day that goes by, it becomes clearer that Hamas’ rule in Gaza is a dictatorship. While it is true that Hamas won parliamentary elections in 2006, there hasn’t been another election since 2006. As such, any legitimacy that Hamas previously had is no longer valid. They show no sign of holding an election because they know that the population is increasingly disillusioned and eager for change.
The West Bank consists of three areas:
- In Area A, the PA is the sole authority, there are no Israeli settlements, and Israelis are forbidden from entering except for security purposes.
- In Area B, there is joint control by the PA and Israel, and there are no Israeli settlements.
- Israeli settlements exist only in Area C, which is under full Israeli civil and security control. The vast majority of Palestinians in the West Bank live in Areas A and B and, therefore, are under total or partial control of the PA.
Palestinians, however, do not feel that they are well-represented by the PA, and Abbas has stated that he will not permit elections in the West Bank unless simultaneous elections take place in Gaza. Since Hamas rules Gaza with an iron fist and will not permit elections, Abbas’ stance practically means that he is allowing Palestinian democracy to be held hostage by Hamas.
Outside Israel and the Palestinian territories, much of the world sees us through the lenses of the Boycott, Divest, Sanction (“BDS”) movement – which Palestinians largely do not support. Since the Palestinian-controlled economy is so weak, many Palestinians are employed by Israeli firms — the only source of good jobs for Palestinians. The BDS movement, however, is not interested in hearing the Palestinians’ pleas because they would rather see Palestinians live in poverty than relent in their pursuit against Israel.
The BDS movement and other anti-Israel activities use Israeli settlements in the West Bank to demonize Israel, but they do not seem to understand that the building of settlements benefits Palestinians. The settlements are a great source of well-paying jobs for Palestinian workers, and you can even say that the Palestinians essentially build the settlements. Jews residing in the West Bank is not a problem. Why should it be? Muslims live all over the world, so why should there be areas where Jews are not allowed? That would be apartheid.
We all know how the conflict with Israel started. Arab leaders saw war against the Jews as a way to create a convenient “enemy” that they could use to keep their people subjugated while the Arab leaders, their families, and their cronies lived the high life. The Arab world is almost one thousand times larger than Israel, so the existence of Israel was never a threat to the Arab world, but it was a great opportunity to allow corrupt Arab leaders to keep their peoples distracted. This is the tragedy of the Arab nations, and they need to deal with it themselves – and we Palestinians are tired of paying the price for it.
Despite the Arabs’ betrayal of the Palestinians, today’s situation is in our hands. We cannot expect our situation to improve while terrorism continues and while Palestinian youth are taught to believe that killing Jews – even Jewish children – is honorable. It is not honorable, and such hate will never benefit the Palestinians.
The BDS movement, which claims to be our friend, is determined to blame Israel for all our problems, and refuses to acknowledge the true issues. Instead, they are engaged in a self-serving narrative aimed at making them look like heroes who are supposedly helping the Palestinians. If they truly were our friends, they would open their eyes and help resolve the real issues.
If so-called pro-Palestinian activists truly want to help the Palestinians, then they should demand freedom, human rights, democracy, and justice for the Palestinians. They should demand that the incitement of Palestinians stop. They should assist Israel in creating jobs in the West Bank for Palestinians. They should assist Palestinians in developing an economy while ensuring that the money is not used to enrich the terrorists’ rule or to augment the terrorists’ arsenal. The should encourage Palestinians to live in peace with Jews. If and when these things happen, a permanent solution will be found. Until then it is waste of time to even talk about it.
3. Purchase your tickets: Beit Tikva Concert starring Cantor Ephraim Herrera, June 4, 3:00 pm at Beit Tikva